RE: and sometimes i thing people that comment on peoples work can be a little too brutal.Two things: 1) you have to develop a skin if you're going to put something in front of an audience. Whether dance, music or painting, there are going to be people who love what you do and people who'll hate it. And the skill is to hear the germ behind the critique.
RE: cause i think the best way to build an artist is to give them a pat on the bach ,the rest they will learn in time
I disagree. A pat on the back is one thing, but sometimes a kick in the ass is good too. One of the reasons why visual art went from something of a craft with skill and training to the stereotypical foppish guy in a beret throwing random blotches of color on a board and calling it "Art" is because noone said "this is crap" when it first showed up. If we'd had the guts to take the works of Paul Klee and publicly burn them when they first showed up, then none of the rest of this dilletante nonsense would be plaguing us today.
A violin teacher will not accept sloppy fingering, nor will he accept off-tune notes or bad time keeping. If you're going to play the violin, damn it, you'd better hit every note on key. However, that being said, there's a difference between saying "I'm sorry, please stop there, we need to work on the way you hold that thing before anything else" and bringing a ruler down on the student's fingers, screaming "get that horrible yowling thing out of here!"